Tales That Defy the Ordinary

Sharp takes on film, culture, history, nostalgia, and the curious corners of human life. With side-glances at nature, thought, and satire. Jackdaw Posts isn’t your average blog. Not quite a magazine.

But always worth the read.

Mary Celeste: The Sea’s Greatest Vanishing Act

It’s December 1872. The Atlantic lies cold and open, the sky blank and bleached as bone.
And there she is—sails slack, crew vanished, breakfast half-eaten.
A ship, intact. A crew, erased.
The Mary Celeste floats on, missing everything but herself.

It would become the most famous maritime mystery of the age. But this wasn’t just a spooky story for sailor bars. This was the Victorian psyche sprung a leak—superstition, empire, and moral superiority—all slipping beneath the waves.

 

Illustration of the ghost ship Mary Celeste adrift at sea
Where the crew went, only the sea knows.

Born Under a Bad Star: The Cursed Ship’s Early Years

Before she became the Mary Celeste, she was called Amazon, and from the start, she seemed hellbent on misfortune.

Built in Nova Scotia in 1861, she was involved in multiple accidents—collisions, fires, captain dying on her maiden voyage. Sailors are a superstitious breed, and Amazon quickly gained a reputation as an unlucky ship. Eventually salvaged, refitted, and renamed Mary Celeste in 1868, the name change was supposed to break the curse.

It didn’t.

This was an age when the ocean was feared as much as it was relied on. Vessels weren’t just tools of trade—they were avatars of fate. A ship with a bad past might as well have been crewed by ghosts from the start.

 

1861 painting of the Mary Celeste sailing at sea
An 1861 painting of the Mary Celeste, by an unknown artist.

The Voyage Begins: Spirits on Board, and Not Just in Bottles

On November 7, 1872, the Mary Celeste set sail from New York bound for Genoa, Italy. Her cargo: 1,701 barrels of denatured alcohol. Her crew: seven men, a respected captain named Benjamin Briggs, his wife Sarah, and their two-year-old daughter Sophia.

They never made it to Italy. Nor did they leave a single clear clue why.

By the time the Dei Gratia, a British merchant brig, found her drifting 400 miles east of the Azores on December 5, the Mary Celeste had become a floating question mark.

The Scene of the Vanishing

The Dei Gratia crew boarded cautiously. What they found was eerie:

  • No crew.

  • Lifeboat gone.

  • Cargo mostly untouched—though nine barrels were inexplicably empty.

  • The ship was still seaworthy.

  • Food and water on board for six months.

  • Crew’s belongings undisturbed.

  • The captain’s log ended ten days earlier.

There were no signs of violence. No blood. No struggle. No storm damage.

It looked, quite literally, like everyone had stood up and walked off the boat.

Cue the Nonsense: Monsters, Murder, and Martians

This was the Victorian era. Science was on the rise, but spiritualism was trending harder. People believed in ghosts, sea monsters, Atlantis, secret societies, and whatever Charles Fort hadn’t invented yet. When the story hit the press, it exploded.

  • Was it pirates? No valuables were taken.

  • Mutiny? The crew’s pay and clothing were left behind.

  • Seaquake or waterspout? Maybe, but the ship’s condition didn’t match.

  • Giant squid? Come now.

  • Aliens? Conan Doyle might as well have pitched it.

Actually, he sort of did.

In 1884, Arthur Conan Doyle published a fictionalised story about the Mary Celeste (renamed the Marie Celeste for added confusion), involving murder, betrayal, and cannibalism. The British public lapped it up, and folklore did the rest.

The ghost ship was no longer just a maritime mystery—it was pulp material.

Let’s Be Sensible: The Alcohol Fumes Theory

Modern maritime historians and chemists lean towards something less gothic, more chemical.

The denatured alcohol on board was extremely volatile. Nine barrels had leaked—possibly due to inferior porous red oak barrels among the white oak ones. The resulting fumes, trapped in the hold, could have sparked panic.

A sudden loud bang—a pressure build-up or minor explosion without fire—might’ve convinced the crew the ship was about to go up in flames. Briggs may have ordered a temporary evacuation to the lifeboat, tethered it to the ship, and intended to wait it out.

But a rogue wave or sudden weather shift could have snapped the line. One bad knot, and they were adrift in open water, lost forever. Meanwhile, the Mary Celeste, empty but unharmed, carried on without them.

It’s tragic. But it’s also painfully human—rational panic, wrong decision, irretrievable loss.

The Inquest: Bureaucracy Meets Ghost Story

When the Dei Gratia towed the Mary Celeste into Gibraltar, salvage laws kicked in. The court opened an inquiry. And as is tradition with British institutions faced with ambiguity, it opted for suspicion.

The Dei Gratia crew were grilled. Had they murdered the Mary Celeste’s crew and faked the scene? Plundered her and spun a yarn? There was no evidence, but plenty of insinuation.

In the end, they were granted a salvage award—just £1,700 out of a potential £8,000. The court couldn't prove wrongdoing, but it couldn't stomach rewarding a mystery either. Victorian morality preferred answers, even if fabricated.

The Press: Mystery as Commodity

The British and American press had a field day. A ghost ship with no blood and no storm? Better than a penny dreadful. It fit neatly into the era’s neuroses: fear of the unknown, anxieties about imperial decline, and distrust of modernity.

A vanished crew left the public with a rare treat—terror without guilt. It was horror without consequence. No one to hang, no body to bury, no answer to shout down.

In an age that worshipped order and control, the Mary Celeste was chaos at sea.

What Happened to the Ship?

You might expect the Mary Celeste to sink quietly, dignified, mysterious to the end.

She didn’t.

She kept sailing for over a decade. But her luck never improved. She was bought and sold repeatedly. Her new captains hated her. Her crews mutinied or went mad. In 1885, her final owner deliberately wrecked her off Haiti in an insurance scam.

No dramatic explosion. No sea monster. Just slow descent into irrelevance, fraud, and rot.

Even ghosts get boring when they don’t pay.

Why We Still Care: The Comfort of Uncertainty

Here’s the thing: we don’t need the truth about the Mary Celeste.
In fact, we like that we don’t have it.

We need these mysteries. They remind us that the sea is still bigger than us. That sometimes, all the charts and checklists, all the order and progress in the world, won’t stop a good ship from drifting alone across the Atlantic, her crew dissolved like salt.

The Mary Celeste is not a riddle waiting to be solved. She’s a monument to that little room in the human mind where mystery lives rent-free.

And we’d rather leave the door ajar.

 


Ghost Ship Mary Celeste: The 150 Year Mystery — Part-Time Explorer, YouTube Channel.

Further Reading

Most Popular — Of All Time

The Rocketeer (1991) – A Good Idea That Never Quite Takes Off

Image
Los Angeles, 1938. The world is on the brink of war. Hollywood is a neon-lit dream, full of gangsters, movie stars, and fast-talking dames. A stunt pilot finds a rocket pack and suddenly, he’s dodging bullets and soaring above the city like something out of a pulp magazine. Sounds like the perfect adventure, right? It should be. But The Rocketeer —Disney’s 1991 tribute to old-school serials and mid-century swashbuckling—never quite takes off. It’s a film that looks great, has all the right ingredients, but never fully commits to the thrill. It wants to soar. Instead, it hesitates.   Movie poster by John Mattos   A Throwback to a Time That Never Was Directed by Joe Johnston (yes, the guy who later gave us Captain America: The First Avenger ), The Rocketeer is pure pulp adventure, a love letter to old serials, comic books, and a time when heroes wore leather jackets and flew with reckless abandon. It’s based on Dave Stevens’ 1982 comic, itself a nostalgic nod to the 1930s. The...
Read more

Climbing Higher, Breathing Less: The Reinhold Messner Way

Image
They say the mountains don’t care. They don’t care if you’re strong or weak, bold or afraid. They don’t care if you’re Reinhold Messner or some guy who thought hiking boots were optional. But Messner cared. Not about the mountains’ indifference, but about meeting them on their own brutal terms. No oxygen tanks. No safety nets. No excuses. Just a man, a summit, and the thin line in between called survival.   One man, one mountain, no mercy. The Man Who Climbed Before He Climbed Reinhold Messner was born on September 17, 1944, in Brixen, South Tyrol, a rugged sliver of northern Italy where the Dolomites rise like broken teeth against the sky. He grew up in their shadow, which is perhaps the best place to grow if you intend to spend your life chasing summits. By five, he was climbing peaks most kids wouldn’t dare draw. His father, a stern schoolteacher with military roots, taught him discipline. The mountains taught him everything else. Messner’s Mountaineering Philosophy Before Messn...
Read more

USS Eldridge and the Philadelphia Experiment: Fact, Fiction, or Cover-Up?

Image
In 1943, a U.S. Navy ship supposedly vanished—then reappeared miles away. The story of the Philadelphia Experiment has baffled, thrilled, and amused ever since. Was it science, myth, or something stranger lurking beneath the waves? Let's lift the fog. The Philadelphia Experiment: When War Met Wonder and Vanished Project Rainbow: War Games and Wishful Thinking The world burned. Steel-clad ships cut the Atlantic. And somewhere in a Navy lab thick with wires and ambition, a strange idea flickered to life. The story begins with Project Rainbow , a hush-hush U.S. Navy initiative whispered to involve more than sonar and sweat. According to lore—and we stress the lore—they weren’t just building ships. They were building ghosts . Invisible ones. Enter the USS Eldridge , a destroyer escort built for the nuts and bolts of convoy protection. But it was picked for something grander. Something science-fictional. The plan? Wrap it in electromagnetism. Bend light. Maybe bend time. Make i...
Read more

Not Quite Trending. Not Quite Dead. Too Stubborn to Die.